Puzzle 15 Solution

The 4 phrases said by the men are actually rephrased versions of Christmas carols.

The first one is: Joy to the World
The second one is: Away in a Manger
The third is: I'm Dreaming of a White Christmas
The fourth is: Little Drummer Boy

Taking note of the first letters of each carol, you get the word JAIL, which is where Andrew will be brought to. Oh dear. (:

Answer: jail